Wednesday, January 7, 2009

IK Multimedia T-RackS 3 Deluxe £349 (PC/ MAC)

It's known across the computer music globe for ease of use and sonic prowess, but is version 3 of this mastering suite a roaring success?

A popular product ever since the release of the first version way back in 1999, IK Multimedia's T-RackS mastering software has become a bona fide computer music classic. What appealed most about the early versions of T-RackS was the combination of impressive analogue-esque sonics and a simple, intuitive user interface. It remained largely unchanged with subsequent versions, which brought such features as 24-bit audio support and separate plug-in versions of each of its four modules. Come 2008, IK Multimedia have finally released a new version: T-RackS 3. But, does it meet demanding modern standards?

Run for your life
T-RackS 3 can run as a plug-in suite inside your DAW, but you can't load individual processors as single VST plug-ins as with older versions. It uses a 'shell' system, a bit like IK's AmpliTube range. The software also works as a standalone audio mastering solution, which differs only in that it has a simple audio editor for adding fades and automated mastering changes, and lets you render out to audio files.

If you buy the Classic version of T-RackS 3, you get the same four processors as the original, albeit in spruced-up form - see boxout. However, the real excitement is over the Deluxe edition, which we're focusing on here. This boasts five additional, brand-new processors.
There are three new 'analogue' modules: the Vintage Tube Compressor, Vintage Tube Program Equaliser and Opto Compressor. These are based on the legendary Fairchild 670 tube compressor, the similarly illustrious Pultec EQP-1A equaliser, and an unspecified optical compression design respectively. Rounding things off in thoroughly digital style are the Brickwall Limiter and Linear Phase Equaliser.

Rack'em up
The familiar T-RackS GUI has been overhauled: what was previously a fixed rack of effects is now a more complex and versatile modular affair. You can only see one module at a time in the main window (the interfaces are rather hefty), while the metering section sits at the bottom and is ever-present.
Up top, there are 12 processing slots,

"The new analogue' plug-ins impressed us the most bringing some of that warm and punchy magic"

arranged as two parallel four-slot chains, followed by a final serial chain of four. This gives plenty of parallel processing potential, eg, using two types of compression at once, or applying frequency-dependent compression/limiting, for example. The new Linear Phase EQ comes in handy for the latter application, helping to avoid phasing issues that can arise with regular EQs.

While you can view the processing chain in schematic format, it's a real disappointment -quite a surprise, in fact - that you can't drag and drop effects to reorder them. IK Multimedia tell us that this will be added in an update.

More well-conceived is the Compare section, which balances the volume of the original and mastered audio, for making comparisons without being blindsided by differing volume levels. The A/B/C/D compare panel is another winner, enabling you to set up four mastering chains and flip between them instantly.

As for the metering, it's a welcome addition, but it's annoying that you can't switch it off or hide it away, as it's not always useful and takes up a fair bit of screen space. However, it is extremely customisable, with the perceived loudness meter very helpful when trying to maintain a consistent-sounding level.

The stereo phase meter is slightly redundant considering there's no dedicated stereo imaging module. The new EQs and compressors have mid/side modes, though, which can be used to manipulate the stereo image, and the Classic Compressor has a stereo-tweaking function. IK say that they intend to add further modules in the future - a stereo tool wouldn't go amiss.

Putting T-RackS through it's paces, the new 'analogue' plug-ins impressed us most, bringing some of that elusive warm and punchy magic to your tracks. The Fairchild and Pultec emulations are comparable to those of Universal Audio's renowned UAD system, which is to say that they're rather good indeed. The EQ helps to take the harsh edge off digital-sounding material, while still brightening it up. However, our favourite is the Opto Compressor, which is blessed with a fantastic sound that makes it a contender for best native software compressor.

Another brick in the wall
The Brickwall Limiter has numerous modes, offering different 'flavours' of limiting. It's great for making mixes louder than they've any right to be, though it's not as transparent as, say, PSP Xenon. The Linear Phase EQ offers exactly what you'd expect: equalisation without colouration.

In the highest-quality mode, with linear phase operation and oversampling engaged, T-RackS 3 can be very CPU hungry. Which is fine for mastering, but if you're using T-RackS 3 for mixing, you'll want to enable the Lowest Latency mode, which disables the CPU-guzzling oversampling, although it's still no lightweight.

Overall, both T-RackS 3 bundles represent solid value for money. You can achieve great mastering results with minimal fuss, and the processors work great in the mix, too. Some of the interface issues - such as the inability to reorder effects or hide meters - are frustrating and take the edge off things, so we'll certainly be looking forward to those updates! cm

Contact: IK Multimedia UK, 0800 0934066
Web: www.ikmultimedia.com
Info: Standard version, £138 Deluxe version crossgrade, £211
≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌

You can view the effects chain and see how the modules are arranged, though you can't drag and drop 'em, sadly
≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌

The Classic Compressor and Equalizer sound better than ever in T-RackS 3

Jurassic classics

The Standard version of T-RackS is significantly cheaper at £138, though it only carries the four original T-RackS modules, now termed Classics: Equalizer, Compressor, Multiband Limiter and Clipper. These are functionally identical to previous releases, but have apparently undergone an audio path update to bring them up to v3's standards. They can make use of the same high-quality oversampling modes too.

We can report that the Standard version as a whole is great value for money and that its modules can definitely benefit your tracks. The minimalist controls help you to concentrate on the sound, and they still stand up today as useful audio tools, with a warm, characterful quality. The Compressor in particular works well on everything from basslines to vocals.

That said, things aren't quite perfect. The Multiband Limiter can give decent results, but it's unintuitive to use, and has no solo/bypass or metering per band. It sure doesn't compare to modern multiband processors, which, considering it's T-RackS 3's only such effect, is a tad disappointing. IK say that more sophisticated multiband tools are a possibility in the future, though it's not clear whether they'll come as free updates or as commercial expansions.
≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌

System requirements
(PC) Pentium 2.4GHz/Athlon XP 2.4GHz, 1GB RAM, Windows XP/ Vista VST/RTAS host

(MAC) Dual G4/G51.25GHZ/1.66GHZ Intel Core 2 Duo,
1GB RAM, OS X 10.4,
AU/VST/RTAS host


Test system
(PC) Intel Q6600,4GB RAM Windows XP, Cubase SX3

Alternatively
Sonalksis Mastering Suite £320 cm133» 7/10 » £320
No EQ, but it has a stereo enhancer and a better multiband limiter

iZotope Ozone 4 N/A»N/A»$249
T-RackS's arch rival - see p10 for more info on this forthcoming title

Verdict
FOR
- Audio quality is excellent!
- Emulations add some analogue 'magic'
- Very easy to get good result!
- A/B/C/D compare function

AGAINST
- EatsCPU Iike a T-Rex!
- Interface has some shortfalls
- No dedicated stereo-imaging module
- Multiband Limiter could be better

A few curious omissions hold T-RackS 3 back from true greatness, but there's no denying that it sounds the business

MARK: 8/10
Order Computer Music Magazine from:
http://www.computermusic.co.uk/

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Korg nanoSeries: nanoKey £49, nanoPad £59, nanoKontrol £59 (PC/MAC)

The nanoSeries controllers finally arrives, but do they offer maximum bang for your minimal buck? Let's get twiddling and find out...

There's been an air of expectancy surrounding the nanoSeries here at cm ever since Korg announced the three tiny controllers over the summer. Each of these USB devices is bus-powered, available in stylish black as well as the standard white shown here, and should slot neatly in front of the average 13" laptop. And with a price to match their physical stature, they're certainly cheap enough to tempt you into snapping up the entire range in one fell swoop. But do you really want to be doing that? Read on to find out...

Key change
The nanoKey features 25 velocity-sensitive keys that can transmit either MIDI note or CC (Continuous Controller) data. Further buttons offer octave up/down, pitchbend, modulation and activation of the CC mode. Holding the pitchbend or mod button causes the appropriate MIDI value to automatically rise from the resting point to full (we're slightly disappointed that these buttons aren't pressure sensitive). Visual feedback comes courtesy of a trio of LEDs, the rightmost of which indicates whether CC Mode is active or not. The remaining two convey the current octave: when in the 'middle' octave (C2 to C4), they remain unlit, but show green, orange, red, and flashing red to indicate how far from the centre you are. With CC mode engaged, a green LED comes to life.

Bizarrely, the keys themselves are based on those of a laptop keyboard, as opposed to the ones you'd find on, well, a keyboard that's designed for playing music. They're a fairly good size for such a small unit, but the odd spacing (the black keys are the same width as the white) may baffle practiced keyboardists.

Anybody who's looking for piano-style control probably isn't going to be considering the nanoKey, then. Nevertheless, the feel of the keys - which are plastic, tacky, unresponsive and prone to an occasional 'click' when the inner mechanisms are forced past one another -didn't impress us one jot. Furthermore, the lowest key is directly adjacent to the control area, meaning that a couple of accidental slips onto the buttons is practically a certainty in the heat of a performance.

The nanoKey is adequate for programming

"Anybody who's looking for piano-style control probably isn't going to consider the nanoKey"

basslines, melodies and simple chord sequences, and the price point and portability are undeniably attractive - these factors alone will no doubt be enough for some. In addition, you get a free download of Korg's M1 Le soft synth, as well as an optional upgrade path to their Legacy Digital Edition.

Padding things out

The nanoPad, on the other hand, thoroughly wowed us. The 12 rubber percussion pads are of a decent size and are reminiscent of the famous Akai MPC range, not to mention Korg's own padKontrol. There isn't much travel, but there's enough dynamic response to render your drum programming with plenty of expression, and they feel sturdy enough to stand up to your dextrous drumming digits. The backlit Flam and Roll buttons give more options for rhythmical variation, enabling the easy triggering of their respective embellishments with a single press of the pad. Engaging the Hold button means that when a pad is struck, the MIDI note is held until you hit the pad again or turn the function off.

The truly excellent X-Y pad, which controls the rate of flam and roll in its default mode, is by far the best feature of the nanoPad. Once programmed with the freely downloadable Kontrol Editor software Csee boxout), however, things get much more interesting. Playing a beat on the pads whilst controlling various effect parameters on the X-Y pad is probably the most fun you can have with any of the nanoSeries.

Buying the nanoPad entitles one to a free download of Toontrack's EZdrummer Lite plug-in, with the option of upgrading to the fully-fledged EZdrummer for €79.

On cruise control

Last but not least, we have the nanoKontrol, which offers transport controls and a nine-channel 'mixer', with each strip comprising a slider, rotary knob and two backlit buttons. It's a configuration that lends itself well to a classic volume/pan/solo/mute setup, although you can configure each control to send any CC you like. The transport can send MMC or MIDI CC data.

The nanoKontrol is a surprisingly smooth operator, registering both tiny movements and large sweeps. It doesn't come with any free software, but, as is the case with the nanoKey and nanoPad, there's the option of saving €30 on Ableton's Live 7, LE or Suite.

At this price point (the street prices are even lower!), Korg have worked wonders in providing such an array of controllers, and when you factor their physical dimensions into the equation, you can almost consider the range as a sort of expandable, semi-modular system.

The nanoKey's poor keyboard is a huge letdown, and while it doesn't render it useless, it's definitely not what we were expecting. Why Korg didn't use similar mini-keys to those featured on something like the microKorg is beyond us. One other minor quibble is that while the devices were entirely plug-and-play on the Mac, we had to download and install Korg's USB MIDI driver to get them to work on our Vista PC.

These points aside, we were won over by every aspect of the series' design, and they're bound to appeal to anyone after a cheap, portable yet functional controller or two. cm

Contact: Korg, 01908 857100
Web: www.korg.co.uk
≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌

Kontrolled explosion
The Kontrol Editor application is a free download that gives full access to the nanoSeries' functions. For the nanoKey, you can edit the CC on/off values sent by each key when using CC Mode and their behaviour (momentary or toggle). There are three velocity curves too, as well as fixed-velocity. You can adjust the slide rate when using Pitchbend and set the Mod button's range.

With the nanoPad, CC values and button behaviour can be configured for each pad, and you may stack up to eight MIDI notes per pad, for triggering chords. The funky X-Y controller can control any pair of MIDI CCs you like.

In the nanoKontroi's case, the attack/release time of the buttons can be altered, so that when pressed, the CC does not jump to the new value but glides smoothly - a neat touch! The upper/lower values of the sliders and knobs can be redefined and all controls mapped to the CCs of your choosing.

Crucially, the software enables you to configure up to four scenes for the nanoPad and nanoKontrol, switchable via a button on the device. This effectively gives 48 pads and four X-Y pads for the former and 36 channels and four transport sections for the latter. Complete setups can be saved, so you can create custom ones for your favourite apps or plug-ins.
≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌≌

System requirements
(PC) Windows XP(SP2)/Vista, USB port

(MAC) OS X 10.3.9/10.4.7, USB port

Test system
(MAC) MacBook Air, 1.6GHz Core 2 Duo, 2GBRAM,OS X 10.5.5


Alternatively
Novation Nocturn cm124» 10/10 » £69
Compact controller with a crossfader, touch-sensitive knobs, LED feedback and Automap Universal 2.0 software

Korg microKontrol N/A»N/A»£259
Like having the entire nanoSeries in one package, with much better mini-keys and a funky four-way joystick control

Verdict
FOR
- Super-portable
- Ridiculously affordable
- nanoPad has a great X-Y pad
- Sturdy build of nanoPad/nanoKontrol
- Good sensitivity on nanoKontrol
- Kontrol Editor enhances functionality

Order Computer Music Magazine from:
http://www.computermusic.co.uk/

AGAINST
- Editing not easy for novices
- nanoKey's keyboard is pretty nasty

Each member of the nanoSeries is highly functional and extremely portable, with only the nanoKey's ropey keyboard letting the side down


MARK:
nanoKey 6/10
nanoPad 10/10
nanoKontrol 10/10

Order Computer Music Magazine from:
http://www.computermusic.co.uk/